​

1. Dual Timeline & Structure
How does the alternating 1999 and 2019 timeline shape your understanding of the characters and events? In what ways does this structure build suspense toward the climactic reveal in Texas? 

​

2. Secrets & Silence
Lisa carries decades of silence about the tragedy in Texas. Do you find her decision sympathetic or problematic? What does her withholding reveal about the tension between self‑preservation and truth‑telling?

 

3. Friendship and Forgiveness
Though they were once close, these sorority sisters drift apart after the road trip. What does the novel suggest about the resilience or fragility of long-term female friendship? How do they navigate forgiveness in the present‑day reunion?

 

4. Motivations & Agency
What drives Mary Blake to rally the group for their reunion trip after her divorce? Do you see it as an act of empowerment, escapism, nostalgia—or something else entirely? 

 

5. Cause & Effect Across Time
How do actions and choices in 1999 continue to ripple into the characters’ lives twenty years later? Which moments from the past seem most pivotal—and why?

 

6. Character Growth & Contrast
Compare Helen, Charlie, Annesley, Mary Blake, and Lisa in terms of how they’ve changed (or not) over time. Which character transformation felt the most surprising—or credible—to you?

 

7. Guilt, Loyalty & Promises
Charlie is haunted by a deathbed promise. How does this promise influence her actions in both timelines? What does the novel suggest about loyalty—to others, and to oneself?

 

8. Truth vs. Comfort
At moments of conflict, characters wrestle between maintaining peace and speaking hard truths. How do different characters balance honesty with emotional “comfort”? Is silence ever justified in the novel?

 

9. Themes of Loss & Renewal
The reunion trip becomes both a reckoning and a chance to rebuild. How are themes of grief, regret, and hope interwoven through the journey? How does the physical road trip mirror internal healing?

 

10. Surprise & Closure
Without spoiling the ending too much: how did the final reveal in Texas affect your reading of the whole novel? Did the resolution feel earned—and did it change the way you interpret earlier scenes?